One of the most controversial recommendations in the National Academy of Sciences report on forensic science — Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States: The Path Forward — concerns the removal of crime laboratories from the administrative control of law enforcement agencies. For decades scholars have commented on the “inbred bias of crime laboratories affiliated with law enforcement agencies.” Some commentators have proposed independent laboratories as the remedy for this problem, and in 22, the Illinois Governor’s Commission on Capital Punishment proposed the establishment of an independent state crime laboratory. This essay documents the problems that triggered the NAS Report’s recommendation. It also examines the counter arguments as well as alternative approaches, including additional measures that should protect forensic analyses from improper influence.


Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States, A Path Forward, Forensic Science, Administration, Bias

Publication Date


Document Type


Place of Original Publication

Utah Law Review

Publication Information

Independent Crime Laboratories


2010 Utah Law Review 247 (2010)


COinS Paul C. Giannelli Faculty Bio