Power and Preferences: Developing Countries and the Role of the WTO Appellate Body
Although it is conventional to view the World Trade Organization (WTO) as a law-based regime, we should not underestimate the ways in which state power has molded, and continues to mold, the regime. Understanding the role of power is especially important for our understanding of the relationship between developed and developing countries, the disparity of power between the two has provided the GATT/WTO regime with the challenge of trying to incorporate the powerless developing states into a system that is built on power. We review that challenge in the context of the dispute over the conditions that developed countries impose when they give developing countries preferential trade agreements. Because such preferences are, in theory, gifts, not exchanges, they should be understood as methods by which powerful countries recognize and respond to the powerlessness of the developing countries. Yet as developed countries put more and more conditions on the preferences, they diminish the redistributive character of the preferences, and the preferences begin to look like additional sources of power rather than unilateral gifts to powerless states.
We examine the role of the WTO's Appellate Body in monitoring this dynamic between the powerful and powerless states. Although the Appellate Body performs a judicial, interpretive function, its role in the WTO calls for a far more politically sensitive posture. Without abandoning its interpretive function, the Appellate Body must be attentive to the systemic values that drive the WTO regime. We believe that within the interpretive discretion that it has, the Appellate Body has recognized, and should exercise, the role of monitoring the power relationships between developed and developing countries.
World Trade Organization
Place of Original Publication
North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation
30 North Carolina Journal of International Law and Commercial Regulation 516 (2005)
Gerhart, Peter M. and Kella, Archana Seema, "Power and Preferences: Developing Countries and the Role of the WTO Appellate Body" (2005). Faculty Publications. 1041.